Friday, November 30, 2007

1956 Tennessee

Next week is the awarding of the Heisman Trophy, and this year's voting is already drawing a lot of attention. A certain newspaper covering one of the finalists is conducting an informal media poll and asked for my thougths. Although my newspaper has a vote, I don't, but here's how I would.

My initial thought is that I think a lot of voters are simply going to look at Tim Tebow's touchdown numbers and then nothing else, which shouldn't be the case. That Darren McFadden's season numbers are better than last year, and his career total tops Bo Jackson, could make this one of the interesting and intriguing votes in Heisman history.

1. McFadden, Arkansas
2. Tim Tebow, Florida
3. Glenn Dorsey, LSU

An SEC trifecta, but only because Oregon's Dixon unfortunately got hurt.

Halfback Johnny Majors finished second in 1956 Heisman Trophy voting to Notre Dame’s Paul Hornung (considered one of the most controversial finishes in the award's history), and after a 10-0 regular season Tennessee finished No. 2 in the final polls as well. Courtesy of the Southeastern Conference.

Thursday, November 29, 2007

1962 Southern California

Incoming!

Short and sweet today. Southern California and Wisconsin set numerous passing records as they combined for 853 yards of offense in the 1963 Rose Bowl. Pete Beathard threw four touchdowns passes, including two to Hal Bedsole, as the Trojans held on for a 42-37 victory. Courtesy of the Tournament of Roses archives.

Wednesday, November 28, 2007

1948 Northwestern (and Cal)

I've always really liked this photo. Besides, my mother went to Northwestern.

Aided by a disputed touchdown by fullback Art Murakowski, whose fumble while crossing the goal-line was ruled a score despite photographic evidence to the contrary, Northwestern defeated Cal in the Rose Bowl, 20-14.

Although the Bears came in 10-0 and ranked fourth by the Associated Press, it essentially ended their claim to the national championship. Courtesy of the Tournament of Roses archives.

Tuesday, November 27, 2007

1946 Illinois

Last month I wrote a column speculating on what if the BCS didn’t exist and we had a playoff format in Division I-A (or whatever they’re calling it these days) football.

It was a simple concept, and pretty much the same one they use if every other division. A committee puts together the field, and off we go.

Here’s how it would work. The top team from each of the six major BCS conferences (ACC, Big East, Big Ten, Big 12, Pac-10 and SEC) gets an automatic bid, with the field filled out by the BCS rankings. If conferences want to have a championship game for the automatic bid, that’s fine, and the world can still have a slew of bowl games for the non-playoff teams.

The first round would be at home sites of the higher-ranked seeds, with advancing teams playing at neutral sites of the biggest bowls (Sugar, Orange, etc) along with other high bidders. The committee’s primary job would be to switch teams out of playing conference opponents, and things like that.

Here were the pairings heading in to the Oct. 20 games:

16 at 1: Missouri at Ohio State
9 at 8: West Virginia at Arizona State
12 at 5: Cal at Oklahoma
13 at 4: Kansas at LSU
14 at 3: Southern California at Boston College
11 at 6: Virginia Tech at South Carolina
10 at 7: Oregon at Kentucky
15 at 2: Florida at South Florida

Here’s an update, based on where we are today:

16 at 1: Clemson at Missouri
9 at 8: Florida at Southern California
12 at 5: Boston College at Kansas
13 at 4: Arizona State at Georgia
14 at 3: Tennessee at Ohio State
11 at 6: Hawaii at Virginia Tech
10 at 7: Oklahoma at LSU
15 at 2: Illinois at West Virginia

Florida and Oklahoma are switched to avoid a potential second-round meeting between Oklahoma and Missouri
Boston College and Hawaii are switched to avoid Boston College vs. Virginia Tech

Even if you took the top eight teams, one could make the argument that it would still be much better than what we’re about to see this year, and trust me, that's exactly what people are going to be claiming for the next six weeks or so.
As for the photo, No. 4 UCLA was on pace for an undefeated season when it faced No. 5 Illinois at the 1947 Rose Bowl in the first meeting with a Big Ten/Pac-10 agreement. Led by “Orange” Julius Rykovich (107 yards) and Mr. Five by Five, Buddy Young (103 yards), Illinois won, 45-14. Courtesy of the Tournament of Roses archives.

Monday, November 26, 2007

Covering Alabama (1926)

In an effort to do something different, here's something I wrote for our newspaper blog about what it's like to cover an event like Saturday's Iron Bowl.

With kickoff scheduled for 7 p.m., time would be critical. Even if the game ended in three hours (which would be ridiculously fast), that's 10 p.m., and normally the entire sports section has to completely done and sent to the printer by 11:30 so we can have the paper on subscribers' doorsteps in the morning. Since it was a special event we would get a little extra time, but since the game was being broadcast on ESPN, which meant lots of commercials, we assumed the worst, that it would last at least four hours.

So Executive Sports Editor David Wasson put together our game plan. In addition to photographers, we sent five sports writers and one news writer, Jason Morton. Jamon Smith would write the Page 1A news story, with Jason Smith handling the local scene in Tuscaloosa. Between writers and photographs, that's already more than 10 people covering one event. As usual, Cecil Hurt would write his column, and I handled the game story. That left Tommy Deas to write two Alabama sidebars, Aaron Suttles to hit the home-team locker room for two Auburn sidebars, and Michael Southern to blog during the game, write a final sidebar and contribute an item or two to the notebook (for those not into newspaper lingo, a sidebar is a secondary story usually focusing on one thing, and notes are all the small items we can't fit in anywhere else).


Noon _ Five of the six writers meet at the office in Tuscaloosa. Since Auburn is synonymous with traffic problems, we left seven hours prior to kickoff.

4 p.m. _ With Aaron and Michael crammed into my car, we quickly cruise down through Prattville (I goof on the turn for Steak & Shake, and instead of turning around settle for Hardee's, oh the sacrifices we make) and arrive at Jordan-Hare Stadium in good time, and walk through the crowd to go to work. Thankfully, media is in a new parking lot because in the past we had a problem with fans claiming our spots, and if we argued with them you never knew how you would find your car after the game.

5 p.m. _ After stopping for ribs, Tommy and Jason arrive along with Cecil, whom they met up with in Montgomery. While everyone's watching Kentucky-Tennessee go to four overtimes, I'm dispelling the rumor that some of the Alabama players had been suspended for the game.

7 p.m. _ Kickoff at 7:10. With the wind blowing straight into the press box, it's very cold and Aaron doesn't have a jacket. We tease him unmercifully. Before kickoff, I write up what will be the majority of the lead note regarding Alabama's bowl possibilities. However, a lot will obviously depend on the game's outcome, and I remind myself to double-check everything at the end.

8:45 _ Halftime. With both teams trying to run the ball, the game is moving along very quickly, which is something you can't mention in the press box because you'll jinx it (trust me, the sports gods are cruel that way, especially in baseball). David, sitting in his command chair back in Tuscaloosa and enjoying Florida's win against Florida State, informs us that the deadline for all stories is midnight. It'll be a challenge, and I write up 3-4 paragraphs on the first half and a possible lead for the game story. There are times I'll write 4-5 different leads for a story depending on how a game changes, but for the most part this one held true. Besides, there won't be time to mess with it too much.
Also, the writers huddle and discuss possible sidebars because through the first half there were very few good storylines. Michael is focusing on the defense for his story, but Tommy has very little to work with. Hopefully that will change.

10ish _ When Keith Saunders is called for roughing the passer, I start heading down to the field because I already know what's going to happen. My lead will hold up, the flavor of what I see and hear will add to the story, and, quite frankly, I love being on a field during a game (FYI, reporters are allowed for the final few minutes. That's in part why the sidelines look so much more congested at the end of a game). Replay officials review the touchdown call they nullify as I walk through the concourse, and Auburn punches in the decisive score before I can navigate down a first-level aisle to the ground level. The first thing I notice is that the wind is a lot worse that it appears upstairs. That and I see a whole lot of orange.

10:21 _ The game ends. Now the fun begins. After watching Auburn celebrate and Alabama head off, it's time to hit the interview room, where Saban will have his press conference roughly 15 minutes after the conclusion of the game. Tommy tells me he's greatly concerned about which players will be available, because he can't do a story without quotes. He's right, and now I'm worried too. We figure one story will be on the running game, and talk about backup plans, but everything else will be a question mark.

10:38 _ Dave asks for the rundown of stories, but I can't answer as I obviously don't know yet myself. That and I missed his message because I'm already wedged into a tiny room designed for about 20-25 people with 75-100 journalists and scores of television cameras. Coach Nick Saban is contrite with his remarks and answers about 10 questions. His comment on going recruiting this week stands out to me and I immediately know that will be the last line in my story.
Then the sports information department brings in players to be interviewed. Normally, it's between 12 and 20 players, especially after a win. Instead, we get Travis McCall, John Parker Wilson, Darren Mustin, Wallace Gilberry and Glen Coffee. That's it, or it was when I left the room at about 11 p.m. (Note: I later saw some DJ Hall quotes, so I probably just missed him).

11:10 _ Back upstairs in the press box, check with everyone to see how they're doing and give Dave the rundown, although most of the guys have already done so on their own. Tommy got Coffee for the running backs story, and somehow was going to do a story on how the Alabama players were sick of losing to Auburn. How he would pull that off was beyond me, and the deadline is already looming.

11:50 _ After transcribing three quotes just to make sure I got them right, cranked out the game story in about 30 minutes, gave it a quick read to make sure I didn't have any major mistakes and sent it to the office. As usual, Cecil's the first one done, but everyone else is frantically trying to type with cold fingers and wondering why we don't have the final packet of game stats that are supposed to be handed out after the game.

Midnight _ Finished the notes, checked to see that everyone had sent their stories (incredibly, they all made it on time, or within a couple minutes of deadline), checked my lead note just in time to get the game stats from an Auburn intern. Five minutes later sent a quick correction after realizing I didn't factor in something about Tennessee for the bowl note.

12:15 _ We get the all-clear from the newsroom, but make sure our cell phones ringers are on just in case. By 12:45, David, Harold Stout and Edwin Stanton have laid out the four inside pages -- which includes editing, placing photos, checking cutlines and writing headlines -- along with the photo page, and the front page. With Michael and Aaron back in my small car, we start the long trek home, and it isn't until 1 a.m., when I get a phone signal again, that I find out that the headline is "Deep-Sixed." I like it.

Michael and I realize we had the same Darren Mustin quote in our stories and we duplicated a couple of items about the offense in the notes, but under the circumstances we'll live with it. Knowing Dave, Harold and Edwin the way we do, we know the section will look really good.
3:30 a.m. _ Except for seeing the remains of a horrific accident on 495 (which will unfortunately stay with me for a long time), the drive home is otherwise uneventful and we drop Michael off at the office. After taking Aaron to his place, I head straight for a store to buy orange juice to combat the sore throat that had been bothering me since the fourth quarter. I expect a lot of writers will be under the weather for the next few days. I'm home at 4 a.m. and in bed by 5 a.m. Just another day.
[FYI, if this is something you enjoyed, you may want to check out my book, "No Time Outs: What It's Really Like To Be A Sportswriter Today."
FYI, the photo is from a practice during the 1926 season. Alabama returned to the Rose Bowl and tied Stanford, earning a share of the national championship. Courtesy of the Paul W. Bryant Museum.

Sunday, November 25, 2007

1971 Auburn

Ok, I'm actually out of Auburn photos for "Who's No. 1?" but stole this from one of my other books, "Where Football is King: A History of the SEC."

Hey, sometimes you have to do what you have to do.

Auburn’s Terry Beasley (left) was the favorite target of quarterback Pat Sullivan (right) when he won the Heisman Trophy in 1971. Beasley is one of only two Tigers to reach 1,000 receiving yards in a season. Courtesy of the Bryant Museum.

Saturday, November 24, 2007

The Iron Bowl

Yep, it's more than seven hours prior to kickoff at Auburn, which means it's time to get going because even though the Plains might be a nice to visit, traffic there is about the worst anywhere in sports. Actually, that's only half true, because getting out is a lot worse than getting in. Hopefully it will be a good game.

Quarterback Jeff Rutledge, here taking a snap in the Crimson Tide’s 34-16 victory against Auburn in 1978, led Alabama to 11-1 seasons in both 1977 and a 1978. Alabama finished No. 2 in 1977, but could claim a controversial national championship in 1978. Courtesy of the Paul W. Bryant Museum.

Friday, November 23, 2007

1985 UCLA vs. Iowa

So what was my first inkling of a football rivarly? Believe it or not, it was Iowa-Minnesota, especially since the Iowa fans would invade the Twin Cities whenever they player. The first REAL rivarly game I ever saw was Yale at Harvard. Considering Yale had me up last year to speak to some students, and I have not received a call from Harvard yet, choosing sides on that one is pretty easy for me now.

At 10-1, the 1985 Hawkeyes were still in the title picture heading into a Rose Bowl against UCLA, only to see Bruins backup Eric Ball, who replaced injured Gaston Green, accumulate 227 rushing yards and four touchdowns to lead a 45-28 victory. Photo courtesy of the Tournament of Roses archives.

Thursday, November 22, 2007

1968 Ohio State

Happy Thanksgiving everyone.

It's a holiday, so I'm going to keep this short and sweet ... besides, it's just a few minutes before kickoff for Southern California and Arizona State (FYI, I used to cover the Sun Devils for a bit).

Quarterback Rex Kern was one of 11 sophomores to start for the 1968 Buckeyes, who averaged 32 points and 440 yards per game on offense, while giving up just 15 points and 292 yards on defense. Seven of the sophomore were named All-Americans during their careers. Photo courtesy of the Tournament of Roses archives.
Happy shopping everyone.


Wednesday, November 21, 2007

1947 Michigan

It's the day before Thanksgiving and everyone is in a rush to get somewhere. Me? I'm just looking forward to a couple of days of peace and quiet.

Meanwhile, for some reason, the national media totally jumped on Nick Saban's comments from Monday about reaching rock bottom, more than 24 hours after he made them. Granted, he shouldn't have used 9/11, Pearl Harbor and alcoholism like that, but really, it was pretty obvious to anyone at the press conference that he was trying to make a simple analogy that good things can come out of bad times. Is that a huge national story to me? Not really. Especially not a day after the fact.

Meanwhile, a van driven by former Alabama running back Siran Stacy was struck by a pickup at an intersection and six people were killed, including Stacy's wife and four of his children. The truck was in the wrong lane. If that isn't gut-wrenching, I don't know what is.

Ok, enough of that. Although Notre Dame had already been named the Associated Press’ national champion, Michigan made a very powerful claim by crushing Southern California, 49-0. Jack Weisenburger scored three touchdowns and the Trojans crossed midfield only twice. Courtesy of the Tournament of Roses archives.

Please people, a little perspective.

Happy Thanksgiving. Gobble, gobble.

Tuesday, November 20, 2007

1981 Clemson

So today I went down to the new local Barnes & Noble and signed every book that had of mine, including Who's No. 1? Where Football is King; and Crimson Storm Surge. They had a bunch, and I think they're going to order some copies of No Time Outs.

So if you're looking for a good gift and would like me to sign a book, no problem. I'll sign anything. I'll even sign someone else's book.

Obviously there are numerous other rivarly games this weekend, including Clemson vs. South Carolina. The 1981 Tigers began the season unranked, but quickly began to rise after defeating No. 4 Georgia 13-3 in the only regular loss during Herschel Walker’s career. Photo courtesy of Clemson University.

Monday, November 19, 2007

Rivalry Week (Alabama)

It didn't quite feel like it was Alabama-Auburn week for me until I asked a player today if it felt like it for him, and his eyes got real wide.

Ok, that's good enough for me.

Paul W. “Bear” Bryant’s first national championship with the Crimson Tide came after a 10-0 regular season in 1961 and 10-3 victory against No.9 Arkansas in the Sugar Bowl. Alabama shut out its last five opponents of the regular season. Courtesy of the Paul W. Bryant Museum.

Sunday, November 18, 2007

Rivalry Week (Auburn)

Wow, is it here already? Geez, it seems like last week Michigan was getting beat by a I-AA school (and yes, I know there's another name for it, but I really don't care. People are more confused by the NCAA's new names than my mom is with technology. She still can't figure out the VCR).

Ralph “Shug” Jordan’s 1957 Tigers finished 10-0 for a No. 1 ranking in the final Associated Press poll, but voted No. 2 by the coaches. The Tigers shut out six opponents and never gave up more than seven points, but had been banned from playing in a bowl game due to recruiting violations.

Thus, this month's poll question ...

Photo courtesy of the Southeastern Conference.

Saturday, November 17, 2007

1930 Alabama (and Washington State)

Off to the stadium for the last home game of the season. Funny, I don't think I've ever covered a game before that wasn't at least on pay-per-view. Either that means I'll get more text messages from people wondering what's going on , or far less. It'll probably depend on if there's a significant injury (hope not, I never like to see those).

Alabama captain “Foots” Clement, left, meets the Washington State captain, believed to be Elmer Schwartz, during 1931 Rose Bowl festivities. Unfortunately, we don't know who the woman was, so if anyone does know please drop me a line.

Alabama (10-0) won 24-0, though Notre Dame was considered the consensus national champion. Courtesy of the Paul W. Bryant Museum.

Thursday, November 15, 2007

1937 Cal

I'm going to have to keep this one simple because I've been under the weather the past couple of days (and can only imagine how much worse it would be if I hadn't had a flu shot).

Vic Bottari had 137 rushing yards on 34 carries and scores two touchdowns as Cal defeated Alabama 13-0 to stake a claim for the national title. It six trips to the Rose Bowl, it was Alabama’s only loss, with one tie. Courtesy of the Tournament of Rose achieves.

Wednesday, November 14, 2007

1937 Vanderbilt

Even though the conference has been really beating up on itself, the SEC already has 10 teams bowl eligible, and Vanderbilt is only one win shy with two games to go. The bad news (possibly) for Commodore fans is that the last two games are at Tennessee, which is playing for a spot in the SEC Championship game, and Wake Forest. The really bad news is that even Vandy it gets the sixth W, it doesn't guarantee a bowl invitation because only the Pac 10 and Big 12 will likely not qualify enough teams to meet their postseason commitments.

Led by All-American center Carl “Iron Man” Hinkle, the SEC’s most valuable player, only a last-second field goal by Alabama kept the Commodores out of the Rose Bowl. Courtesy of the Southeastern Conference.

Tuesday, November 13, 2007

1938 Duke (and Southern California)

Any stake Duke had on the national championship vanished with its 7-3 loss to Southern California. The Trojans scored in the final minute when substitute quarterback Doyle Nave completed the last of four straight passes to “Antelope” Al Krueger. The touchdown was the only points scored against Duke all season.

Instead, only Tennessee and Texas Christian were able to claim the national championship. Courtesy of the Tournament of Roses archives.

Monday, November 12, 2007

1933 Michigan

What? Is it really time for Michigan-Ohio State? Somehow I used to associate the game with the end of the season, but it's anything but now. They play, and then they sit while everything else gets sorted out. It just doesn't seem right, and who knows how much it hurt the Buckeyes in the national championship game. Of course, we don't have to worry about that this year, but Saturday's winner will be heading to the Rose Bowl.

Anyway, Despite having no prior football experience, tackle Francis “Whitey” Wistert helped lead the Wolverines to the 1933 national championship, and was the first of three brothers to be enshrined into the College Football Hall of Fame. The others were Albert, who played in 1940-41, and Alvin, 1947-49. Courtesy the Bentley Historical Library (photo BL001313), the University of Michigan.

Sunday, November 11, 2007

1949 Southern Methodist

For Saturday's paper I did a column about the computer polls the BCS uses to compile its rankings. Considering that the computers now have Kansas No. 2 and Arizona State at No. 4, and Hawaii tied for 27th, I thought a few of you might be interested in it.

Here's the link: http://www.tidesports.com/article/20071110/NEWS/71110021/1210/COLUMNS




Doak Walker wasn’t able to win a national championship, but he did just about everything else. He won the Maxwell Award in 1947, the Heisman in 1948, and was named Player of the Year by Collier’s Magazine in 1949. In 35 games he accumulated 288 points, 2,076 rushing yards, 1,786 passing yards (128 of 222 attempts), 454 receiving yards, 750 yards on 50 punt returns, 764 yards on kickoff returns, and averaged 39.6 yards on punts. Courtesy of Southern Methodist University.

Friday, November 9, 2007

1954 Ohio State

I walked into a Books A Million store today and found the book, so I'm two-for-two, and pleased that it's finally getting out there. Now everyone, please go buy it (subtle, huh?).

Having already been named the national champion by the Associated Press, Woody Hayes made a successful debut at the Rose Bowl with a 20-7 victory against Southern California, 20-7. The 1954 Buckeyes were led by quarterback Dave Leggett, while Hopalong Cassady, Bob Watkins and Dick Harkrader all scored a touchdown. Courtesy of the Tournament of Roses archives.

Thursday, November 8, 2007

It's out!

True story.

For those who don't know, this is my fourth book, and after the first three I celebrated by opening a bottle of champagne. I'm not sure why, but this time I didn't ... until last night.

If you haven't noticed, the book has been a little slow getting to stores, primarily because the big database they use listed it as a January 2008 release. So none of them ordered it and the college football season is already beginning to wind down (hey stores, it's available and a perfect holiday gift!).

In order to end the jinx, some friends (Patrick, Carrie, Leah and Ian) helped me kill a bottle of Barefoot Bubbly before watching a movie. Sure enough, today I walked into a Barnes & Noble and there it was, the bright yellow cover I could see all the way across the room.

The champagne worked!

By the way Barefoot Wines, I'm available for endorsements.

Also, thank you Books A Million for updating your website and saying that the book is in stock. Much appreciated.

Although the 1966 Crimson Tide finished a perfect 11-0, neither the Associated Press nor the coaches’ poll awarded Alabama its third consecutive national title, instead ranking it behind both Notre Dame and Michigan State, which tied 10-10. Courtesy of the Paul W. Bryant Museum.

Wednesday, November 7, 2007

1945 Army

Hmmmm ... the talk today on the SEC coaches' conference call was if the six-win minimum for bowl games should be raised. It's a worthwhile question, but no one jumped out and said yes. Can't say I blame them, especially when the question was asked to Vanderbilt's Bobby Johnson (what's he going to say, no?).

So for anyone who thinks the Darren McFadden-Felix Jones backfield at Arkansas might be the best in college football history, I present “Mr. Inside and Mr. Outside.”

Doc Blanchard (right) and Glenn Davis (left) became the only members of the same backfield to both win Heisman Trophies, and be named three-time consensus All-Americans. Blanchard won the Heisman in 1945, Davis In 1946. Davis finished second for the award in both 1944 and 1945. Courtesy of the United States Military Academy.

Tuesday, November 6, 2007

1927 Illinois

A quick book update: Things appear to be progressing nicely now, so if the book isn't in a store near you already it should be very, very soon. Sorry about any delays, and hopefully I can get on with some book signings soon.

Illinois was 7-0-1, with the lone tie against Iowa State, 12-12. However, with Georgia, Notre Dame and Yale all sustaining a loss, Illinois is considered the consensus national champion. Courtesy Illinois Sports Information Archives.

Monday, November 5, 2007

1940 Stanford

Here's something to mull over during the final three weeks of the college football regular season:

Houston became the 49th team to become eligible for postseason play after Sunday's win over SMU. Twenty-six other squads are just one victory away from achieving the necessary six wins in a 12-game regular season to play in a bowl game.
There's just one problem, there are only 32 bowl games, with obviously 64 teams. The SEC alone has nine teams with six wins or more, with two more at five. In short, some teams are going to be left out.
Remember, you heard it here first.
With Clark Shaughnessy’s new innovation, the T-formation, Pete Kmetovic had 141 rushing yards and returned a punt for a touchdown to lead Stanford’s 21-13 victory against Nebraska in the 1941 Rose Bowl. Stanford received national title consideration, but Minnesota was the consensus choice. Courtesy of the Tournament of Roses archives.

Sunday, November 4, 2007

1931 Southern California

Southern California coach Howard Jones led the Trojans to five appearances in the Rose Bowl and won them all, including the 21-12 victory against Tulane to help secure the 1931 national championship. Courtesy of Tournament of Roses archives.








Bonus picture

This is actually a photo I took last year, but you have to give props to the Tigers for pulling out last night's game, even though they all but tried to give it away at times.

Overall, I have to say that LSU-Alabama was one of the more entertaining games I've seen in a long time, and considering the Tide has already had five games go down to the wire this season that's really saying something.

So congrats to LSU.

Saturday, November 3, 2007

1992 Alabama

Well, I severely doubt we're going to see anything like this today, but it still should be an interesting day.

Coach Gene Stallings is carried off the field at the 1993 Sugar Bowl after Alabama (13-0) became the first team to win the national championship under the new Bowl Coalition. Courtesy of the Paul W. Bryant Museum.

Friday, November 2, 2007

1966 Notre Dame

The October poll is obviously over, and here are the results:

For the question, which Notre Dame title (or non-title) is the most controversial?
1966: "Tie one for the Gipper" 56 (84%)
1946: The most famous tie in college football history 6 (9%)
1947: The vote that didn't count 3 (4%)
1993: "But we beat Florida State" 1 (1%)

Basically, you're all in line with the book, which does include a top 10 list of all-time.
Nick Eddy (No. 47), here making a move with Rocky Bleier just below him (No. 28), was Notre Dame’s leading rusher and finished third in Heisman Trophy voting, but didn’t play in the biggest game of the year, the 10-10 tie against Michigan State. He slipped getting off the train at East Lansing and aggravated his shoulder injury. Courtesy of the University of Notre Dame.

Bonus picture

So yes, I did take off from the blog yesterday, but primarily because it was one of those days I left home and didn't come back until incredibly late. It's also because I went and saw Cowboy Mouth last night - excellent show, had a great time. FYI, a lot of CBS people were there as well.

Tuscaloosa is being invaded by Alabama, LSU and college football fans in general. I'm having a quiet night to rest up for what should be a heck of a big day Saturday. I'm looking forward to it.